Comparison of the effect on two approaches of total knee arthroplasty

GENG Lei,CHEN Jiying,CHEN Cheng,ZHANG Guoqiang,CHAI Wei,XU Meng,LU Qiang,SONG Junlei

Medical Journal of the Chinese People Armed Police Forces ›› 2012, Vol. 23 ›› Issue (5) : 373-375.

PDF(643 KB)
PDF(643 KB)
Medical Journal of the Chinese People Armed Police Forces ›› 2012, Vol. 23 ›› Issue (5) : 373-375.

Comparison of the effect on two approaches of total knee arthroplasty

  • GENG Lei,CHEN Jiying,CHEN Cheng,ZHANG Guoqiang,CHAI Wei,XU Meng,LU Qiang,and SONG Junlei.
Author information +
History +

Abstract

Objective To investigate the clinical difference between midvastus and medial parapatellar approaches in total knee arthroplasty.  Methods  Twenty-five patients undergoing bilateral total knee arthroplasty in this hospital from January 2009 to January 2010 were retrospectively studied. One randomized side of each patient was treated using the midvastus approach and the other side using the medial parapatellar approach.The operation duration, postoperative drainage amount,range of motion 6 weeks after operation, time to resume straight leg raises and the VAS score of each knee in the postoperative 1,2,3 and 6 days were observed.  Results  The midvastus approach group far outperformed the medial parapatellar approach group in the time to resume straight leg raises and VAS scores(P<0.05). However,they had no significant difference in the drainage amount,operation duration and range of motion 6 weeks after operation (P >0.05).  Conclusions  Compared with midial parapatellar approach, the midvastus approach in total knee arthroplasty causes less pain postoperatively, takes less time to resume straight leg raises and brings about quick recovery to knee function.

Cite this article

Download Citations
GENG Lei,CHEN Jiying,CHEN Cheng,ZHANG Guoqiang,CHAI Wei,XU Meng,LU Qiang,SONG Junlei. Comparison of the effect on two approaches of total knee arthroplasty[J]. Medical Journal of the Chinese People Armed Police Forces. 2012, 23(5): 373-375

References

[1]CilaE,GüzelV,OzalayM,etal.Subvastusversusmedialparapatellarapproachintotalkneearthroplasty[J].Archivesoforthopaedicandtraumasurgery,2002,122(2):65-68.

[2]BrickGW,ScottRD.Thepatellofemoralcomponentoftotalkneearthroplasty[J].Clinicalorthopaedicsandrelatedresearch,1988,(231):163-178.

[3]EnghGA,HoltBT,ParksNL.Amidvastusmuscle-splittingapproachfortotalkneearthroplasty[J].TheJournalofarthroplasty,1997,12(3):322-331.

[4]张秀芬,权伍成,彭珊,等.针刀松解对膝骨性关节炎足部生物力学及X线表现的影响[J].武警医学,2011,22(10):872-875.

[5]BthisH,PerlickL,BlumC,etal.Midvastusapproachintotalkneearthroplasty:arandomized,double-blindedstudyonearlyrehabilitation[J].KneesurgeryofficialjournaloftheESSKA,2005,13(7):545-550.

[6]MaestroA,SuarezMA,RodriguezL,etal.Themidvastussurgicalapproachintotalkneearthroplasty[J].Internationalorthopaedics,2000,24(2):104-107.

[7]OzkocG,HersekliMA,AkpinarS,etal.Timedependentchangesinpatellartrackingwithmedialparapatellarandmidvastusapproaches[J].KneesurgeryofficialjournaloftheESSKA,2005,13(8):654-657.

[8]DaluryDF,JiranekWA.Acomparisonofthemidvastusandparamedianapproachesfortotalkneearthroplasty[J].TheJournalofarthroplasty,1999,14(1):33-37.

[9]LaskinRS.Surgicalexposurefortotalkneearthroplasty:foreverythingthereisaseason[J].TheJournalofarthroplasty,2007,22(4Suppl1):12-14.

[10]〖JP3〗MukherjeeP,PressJ,HockingsM.Mid-vastusvsmedialpara-patellarapproachintotalkneereplacement-timetodischarge[J].TheIowaorthopaedicjournal,2009,29:19-22.

[11]〖JP4〗DaiXsong,YuXzhong,WuLdong,etal.Useofmid-vastusapproachinlessinvasiveprimarytotalkneearthroplasty[J].Chinesemedicaljournal,2008,121(9):787-790.
PDF(643 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/